Starfield Allows Marrying Multiple Companions, Confusing Players

Starfield player marries Sarah and Andreja after passing persuasion check
Community confused as players thought you couldn't romance both characters
Sarah will accept proposal even if player is with Andreja first
Game allows flirting with other companions after marriage
Unclear who player's character sleeps next to when both wives are present

dexerto.com

Relevant topic timeline:

9/5/2023

Starfield romance options and how relationships work

Romance in Starfield allows players to deepen their relationships with select companions, unlock companion quests, and even marry one of them, with each romance interest having their own preferences and questlines.

9/10/2023

Starfield Mission Forces Tough Choice, Companion Death

In the video game Starfield, players are faced with a difficult decision where they must choose which companion to save, leading to lasting consequences and impacting the rest of the gameplay.

9/30/2023

Starfield Player Accidentally Marries Two Companions Due to Possible Marriage System Bug

A player in Bethesda's Starfield RPG found themselves married to two spouses, sparking a debate as to whether it's a bug or a planned feature.