Supreme Court Faces Calls for Reform Amid Growing Politicization Concerns

The Supreme Court returns amid controversy over its perceived politicization and calls for ethics reform.
Chief Justice Roberts seeks to defend the court's legitimacy but struggles to respond to critics.
Conservative justices like Alito reject proposals for ethics codes and Congressional oversight.
Liberal justices like Kagan and Kavanaugh seem open to some ethics reforms for the court.
Institutional inertia makes rapid change unlikely as the court moves slowly by tradition.

cnn.com

Relevant topic timeline:

9/5/2023

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse files ethics complaint over Justice Samuel Alito interview

Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse is calling on Chief Justice John Roberts to address an interview in which Justice Samuel Alito questioned Congress' authority to impose ethics rules on the Supreme Court, highlighting the lack of a formal mechanism for handling ethics complaints within the Court.

9/13/2023

Durbin Calls Out Supreme Court's Ethics Issues to Chief Justice Roberts

Democratic Senator Dick Durbin called out the U.S. Supreme Court's ethics problems to Chief Justice John Roberts' face, emphasizing the need for an enforceable code of conduct for the justices and expressing disappointment in the court's ethical crisis, which has led to a decline in public support and controversies involving several justices.

9/16/2023

CJ Bandial's Tenure Marked by Inconsistencies and Failures to Uphold Constitution

Chief Justice (CJ) Bandial of the Supreme Court of Pakistan is criticized for failing to uphold the Constitution, making contentious decisions, and showing a lack of leadership and accountability.

9/22/2023

Thomas's Undisclosed Koch Ties Spark Ethics Outrage and Calls for Recusal or Resignation

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas is facing backlash and calls for recusal after a report revealed his undisclosed participation in events organized by the hard-right Koch network, raising concerns about ethics violations and potential bias in upcoming cases.

Topics

Posted 9/26/2023, 9:30:00 AM