1. Home
  2. >
  3. Technology 🛠️
Posted

Starfield's Metacritic Score Slides to 84 as Reviews Paint a Divided Picture

  • Starfield's Metacritic score has slid from an 88 at launch to an 84 for Xbox Series X as more reviews have come in.

  • An 84 puts Starfield as Xbox's 47th highest rated game of the generation, behind many other Xbox exclusives.

  • Starfield's 84 is tied with Fallout New Vegas for the lowest mainline Bethesda game on Xbox.

  • There is a huge divide between critics who love Starfield and those who find it mediocre.

  • It remains to be seen how Starfield will be viewed in hindsight, but its Metacritic score is lower than Bethesda likely hoped.

forbes.com
Relevant topic timeline:
Bethesda's new RPG, Starfield, utilizes procedural generation to create over a thousand explorable planets, but this approach leads to dull and repetitive gameplay, highlighting the need for a balance between AI-generated content and hand-crafted design.
Starfield, the highly anticipated space RPG from Bethesda Game Studios, is finally available on PC and Xbox Series consoles, offering players a vast and immersive space adventure with numerous activities and the potential to become a Game of the Year contender in 2023.
Starfield, the highly anticipated game from Bethesda, is now available on Xbox Series X|S and PC, and Xbox Game Pass Ultimate subscribers can play it on Xbox One through Xbox Cloud Gaming.
Bethesda development chief Todd Howard has highlighted the advantages of Starfield being exclusive to Xbox, emphasizing the ability to focus on one console and deliver a better product, similar to the brand association Nintendo enjoys with its first-party games.
Starfield, the biggest Xbox game of the year, is now available on Game Pass, and players are faced with the task of making important choices during character creation, including selecting a background and traits that will impact their gameplay style.
Bethesda's new game Starfield has received positive reviews but also criticism for bugs and visual detail, with a viral video comparing it to Cyberpunk 2077; however, Cyberpunk 2077's senior quest designer argues that the comparison is unfair and hypocritical.
Starfield development chief Todd Howard responded to why Bethesda hadn't optimized Starfield for PC, stating that the game is running great and is a next-gen PC game, suggesting that players may need to upgrade their PCs to fully enjoy the game.
Bethesda's latest RPG, Starfield, achieves a record-breaking launch with over 6 million players, surpassing previous Bethesda games like Fallout and The Elder Scrolls.
Bethesda Softworks' upcoming game Starfield has faced criticism for its poor facial detailing and racial biases in character designs, highlighting the studio's lack of care and recklessness in creating a diverse world in the laziest way possible.
Jim Stephanie Sterling, a well-known video game critic, gives Starfield a poor score of 4/10, citing repetitive gameplay, unimpressive graphics, and a lack of creative ambition, but acknowledging that it has some redeeming qualities.
Starfield, the demanding PC game, is optimized for AMD GPUs and CPUs but not so much for Intel and Nvidia systems, leading to poorer performance on the latter platforms, according to experts at Digital Foundry.
The global COVID-19 pandemic caused a significant slowdown in the production of Starfield, resulting in the game's release being delayed to September 2023, according to game director Todd Howard.
Bethesda has announced upcoming quality-of-life improvements and expanded graphical options for Starfield, starting with a hotfix to address bugs and stability, and following with features such as support for Nvidia's DLSS tech, an FOV slider, HDR customisation, and mod support in early 2024.
Larian Studios defends Bethesda against criticism, saying it's not true to suggest the developers lacked passion for Starfield, following comparisons between Baldur's Gate 3 and Starfield. Former Blizzard developer Mike Kern also attacked Bethesda, but Larian's director of publishing disagrees, calling it a disingenuous oversimplification of game development.
Starfield, the latest sci-fi RPG from Bethesda, has excited Xbox fans with its immersive galactic gameplay, and it has also surprised fans by including the planet Reach from the popular Halo series.
Starfield has achieved over 10 million players since its release on September 1, making it Bethesda's biggest launch ever and the fastest-selling new IP in Europe this year.
Bethesda has released an update for Starfield on Xbox Series X|S and PC, addressing performance and stability issues, as well as gameplay bugs.
Despite its successful launch and high player count, Starfield has received lower scores from Steam players compared to previous Bethesda games, with complaints about stiff NPC facial animations, limited romanceable companions, repetitive content, and other gameplay issues. The studio has a history of releasing updates and DLC, so the game's score may improve over time.
Starfield, the highly anticipated space RPG by Bethesda, has received positive reviews but also faced criticism for its shallow narratives and repetitive environments, leaving some uncertain about its future success and whether it can match the enduring popularity of Skyrim and Fallout. However, with its vast scale, growing modding community, and planned updates and story expansions, Starfield's journey has only just begun.
Starfield has sparked various debates among players, including discussions about where it ranks among Bethesda's titles, with many acknowledging its potential while also recognizing areas for improvement.
Starfield, despite being a single-player game with a clear endpoint, continues to perform well on Xbox and Steam, ranking among the top played games and maintaining a consistent player count, debunking the narrative that it underdelivered or is underperforming.