1. Home
  2. >
  3. Economy 🏛️
Posted

Germany's Economic Woes Exposed by Loss of Cheap Russian Gas

  • Germany was once the envy of the world for its economic success, but is now the worst performing major developed economy after losing cheap Russian gas.

  • High energy costs are threatening Germany's manufacturing sector and "de-industrialization", prompting debates about solutions like an energy price cap.

  • Cracks in Germany's economic foundation have been exposed, including lagging digitalization, bureaucracy slowing green energy projects, and over-reliance on Russian gas.

  • German companies are facing skilled labor shortages, rising costs, and concern about becoming less competitive compared to the U.S.

  • Economists say Germany grew complacent during successful years and failed to address weaknesses, but has room to act with low unemployment and strong finances.

latimes.com
Relevant topic timeline:
### Summary Germany's top economic adviser warns that Germany needs to reduce economic ties with China in order to avoid the risk of conflict if China invades Taiwan. The adviser also highlights the need for Germany to diversify its industries and move away from its reliance on car manufacturing. ### Facts - Germany's top economic adviser, Monika Schnitzer, warns that Germany must reduce economic ties with China to avoid conflict if China invades Taiwan. - The adviser suggests that Germany should not be "naïve" about the risk of China invading Taiwan, and should be more cautious in areas of sensitive technology. - Germany outlined a plan to "de-risk" its relationship with China by reducing dependencies in critical sectors such as medicine and chipmaking. - The country's car manufacturing industry is heavily reliant on China for rare earth minerals necessary for electric car battery manufacture. - Schnitzer argues that Germany is too reliant on car manufacturing and needs to diversify its industries to adapt to changing market demands, particularly in the shift to electric vehicles. - Germany's economy barely grew in the last quarter and is expected to be the only major country to shrink this year, according to the International Monetary Fund. ### 🇩🇪🇨🇳 Germany-China Relations - Germany must reduce economic ties with China to avoid conflict if China invades Taiwan. - Germany outlined a plan to "de-risk" its relationship with China by reducing dependencies in critical sectors. - Germany's car manufacturing industry is heavily reliant on China for rare earth minerals. ### 💼 Germany's Industry Diversification - Germany is too reliant on car manufacturing and needs to diversify its industries. - The shift to electric vehicles has left Germany's car industry behind competitors like Tesla. - Germany's economy barely grew in the last quarter and is expected to be the only major country to shrink this year.
### Summary Germany's economic decline and China's struggles indicate major changes in global politics, challenging previous assumptions about Germany's dominance and China's rise as the world's largest economy. ### Facts - German foreign minister Annalena Baerbock's diplomatic mission to enhance Germany's status in the Indo-Pacific region was derailed when her government's jet broke down, reflecting the country's declining state. - China's official statistics bureau announced it will stop publishing regular youth unemployment figures after the record-high rate of 21.3% for Chinese 16 to 24-year-olds in June. - Germany's economy is in decline, with three consecutive quarters of contraction. The International Monetary Fund predicts slower growth compared to the US, France, and the UK over the next five years. - Angela Merkel's decisions, such as relying on Russian gas and neglecting defense spending, have contributed to Germany's decline. - China's economy, once booming and beneficial for German exporters, is now facing challenges due to a stagnant market, aging population, contracting labor force, and a massive property market bubble. - Foreign investment in China has significantly dropped, and China's position as the world's largest economy is in question. ### Analysis - The decline of Germany and China disrupts previous assumptions about Germany's dominance and China's rise as a global superpower. - Germany's decline opens up opportunities for closer bilateral relations with countries like France and Poland. - The stability and prosperity of Germany remain important for Britain, but it also presents opportunities for the country. - The United States retains its position as the top global power, which is beneficial for Britain as a key ally. - Britain has its own challenges, such as high inflation, slow growth, high taxes, weak infrastructure, and the need to attract dynamic entrepreneurs and innovation.
### Summary European stock markets edged higher, supported by a drop in German producer prices and a smaller-than-expected rate cut from China. German producer prices fell significantly in July, indicating a retreat in inflationary pressures. The European Central Bank is considering a pause in its hiking cycle, which could help alleviate economic difficulties in Germany. In China, the rate cut announced by the People's Bank of China was seen as underwhelming, as analysts had expected a larger cut. The U.K. housing market also slumped, with the fastest decline in August since 2018. Oil prices rebounded, supported by the Chinese rate cut and expectations of lower output from top producers in August. ### Facts - 📉 German producer prices dropped 1.1% in July and fell 6.0% annually, indicating a retreat in inflationary pressures. - 🇩🇪 Economic difficulties in Germany are affecting the eurozone's growth and may lead to a recession. - 🏦 ECB President's speech at Jackson Hole will provide clues on the central bank's next move in September. - 🇨🇳 The People's Bank of China announced a smaller-than-expected rate cut, disappointing analysts. - 🏘️ The U.K. housing market experienced its fastest decline in August since 2018. - 🛢️ Oil prices rose due to the Chinese rate cut and expectations of lower output from top producers.
China's economy, which has been a model of growth for the past 40 years, is facing deep distress and its long era of rapid economic expansion may be coming to an end, marked by slow growth, unfavorable demographics, and a growing divide with the US and its allies, according to the Wall Street Journal.
Germany may be experiencing economic decline, China's youth are growing disillusioned, and AI technology could potentially replace the need to learn foreign languages, according to The Economist's latest podcast.
German business activity, particularly in the services sector, experienced its sharpest decline since May 2020, leading to concerns about the country's outlook for the remainder of the year and potential stagflation, as both manufacturing and services sectors are contracting.
Germany's business activity has seen a sharp decline, leading to concerns of a recession, as the country's Purchasing Managers' Index (PMI) dipped to its lowest level in over three years. This decline in activity is impacting the wider eurozone economy as well, with the region at risk of slipping into recession. This economic downturn is accompanied by a worrying uptick in inflation and slow growth, particularly in Germany.
China's economy is struggling and facing a lurching from one economic challenge to the next due to failures in economic policy and the centralization of power under President Xi Jinping, which is causing bad decision-making and a decline in living standards.
Germany, once known as the "sick man of Europe," is facing a new economic downturn characterized by sticky inflation, falling output, and structural issues such as an aging population and high corporate tax rate, prompting concerns of a prolonged recession; however, the country's strong employment levels, record public finances, and adaptability through its Mittelstand of small and medium-sized businesses provide hope for recovery.
Germany's economy stagnated in the second quarter of 2023, but it has officially emerged from the recession; however, the Bundesbank predicts that the economy will continue to stagnate in the third quarter and the IMF forecasts that Germany will be the only major advanced economy to shrink this year.
The US economy is expected to slow in the coming months due to the Federal Reserve's efforts to combat inflation, which could lead to softer consumer spending and a decrease in stock market returns. Additionally, the resumption of student loan payments in October and the American consumer's credit card addiction pose further uncertainties for the economy. Meanwhile, Germany's economy is facing a contraction and a prolonged recession, which is a stark contrast to its past economic outperformance.
China's economy is facing multiple challenges, including tech and economic sanctions from the US, structural problems, and a decline in exports, hindering its goal of becoming a top global exporter and tech power, which could have long-lasting effects on its status in international relations and the global economy.
Germany's opposition party claims that the country's recession is a result of the bureaucracy surrounding its green energy policies, which are led by The Greens in coalition with the Social Democrats, and warns that the situation will worsen if the excessive bureaucracy and high energy prices are not addressed.
Germany's economy experienced a revival and became a manufacturing powerhouse during the era of globalization.
Russia's invasion of Ukraine and subsequent disruptions in gas supply have caused Europe, particularly Germany, to seek alternative sources of natural gas, leading to a decline in Russia's market share and permanent damage to its reputation as Europe's largest gas supplier.
Germany's economic model and banks are struggling, with forecasts showing low growth and poor profitability, highlighting issues such as politicized governance, diminished private sector, and outdated funding methods.
Euro zone manufacturing shows signs of improvement, while China's private PMI unexpectedly rebounds, offering hope for export-reliant economies, but Germany's manufacturing sector remains in a downturn and factory activity weakens in much of Asia.
Germany is facing economic challenges and high energy prices, which have led to concerns about its energy strategy and the rise of right-wing parties, potentially impacting Germany's ability to achieve its sustainability goals and causing businesses to move operations to countries with cheaper energy.
Germany, once hailed as Europe's economic powerhouse, is now facing structural problems and could be on the verge of decline, according to experts, with factors such as stagnant GDP, high inflation, an aging population, overdependence on exports, and underinvestment contributing to its current predicament.
China's economic growth has slowed but has not collapsed, and while there are concerns about financial risks and a potential property crisis, there are also bright spots such as the growth of the new energy and technology sectors that could boost the economy.
Germany is predicted to experience a prolonged recession this year, making it the only major European economy to contract in 2023, according to the European Commission, with its growth expectations also being cut for 2024; this is attributed to struggles following Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the need to end energy dependency on Moscow.
The European Commission has revised down its economic forecast, citing high prices for goods and services as a significant factor, leading to reduced growth projections for the European Union and the eurozone. Germany is expected to experience a downturn, while inflation is projected to exceed the European Central Bank's target. Weak consumption, credit provisions, and natural disasters are also contributing to the loss of momentum in the economy. However, the report highlights the strength of the EU labor market with a low unemployment rate.
Germany's deep economic troubles, including three consecutive quarters of negative growth, could have significant global implications, especially considering its role as the main driver of economic growth in the euro zone and its high exposure to the Chinese economy.
Germany is projected to be the most heavily impacted by the global economic slowdown due to higher interest rates and weaker global trade, according to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), with its economy likely to shrink this year alongside Argentina and experience a weaker 2024. The slowdown in China, inflationary pressures, and tightening monetary policy are among the factors affecting Germany's growth. The OECD also warned of persistent inflation pressures in various economies and called for central banks to maintain restrictive interest rates until underlying inflationary pressures subside.
Germany is facing an economic contraction due to challenges in the manufacturing sector, a disappointing China reopening boost, and higher energy costs, leading to a recession in Europe's largest economy. However, there are still some positive aspects, such as opportunities in Germany's small and mid-sized companies.
Germany's Green party, led by Annalena Baerbock, is unique for attracting a large share of the vote, occupying the center, and maintaining a consistently hawkish stance on foreign policy; Baerbock's recent trip to the US, including Texas, offered insights into Republican voter support for Donald Trump, Texas' dual energy economy, and the reasons for entrepreneurial and investment growth in the state. However, Germany's energy policy, cyclical economic downturn, digital lag, and infrastructure challenges have resulted in a drop in competitiveness and potential vulnerability to an economic security storm, particularly in the automotive industry with exposure to China. Baerbock's labeling of Xi Jinping as a dictator during her US trip has strained relations further, with potential implications for German car sales and EV production. Germany's efforts to improve competitiveness include using state aid to attract foreign investment and a study by Ursula von der Leyen on the competitiveness of European countries; however, they could learn from small, advanced economies that excel in policy making, capital markets, policy clarity, corporate governance, and coordination with other economies. The larger economies of the world are slower to adapt to changes in the global economy, with the exception of Joe Biden's industrial policy in the US.
Germany, once the beating heart of the European economy, is facing structural challenges and a sense of decline, with forecasts predicting slow growth and contraction in the coming years due to its heavy reliance on manufacturing and struggle to transition to renewable energy and a service-based economy.
Germany's economy is expected to contract in 2023 due to skyrocketing energy prices and political insecurity, but economists are hopeful for a rebound in 2024 as inflation eases and wages increase.
Europe's economy is facing trouble as interest rates rise and debt servicing costs increase, particularly in the eurozone where the European Central Bank will struggle to provide support due to the constraints of the euro; fiscal deficits and breaches of budget deficit limits persist, with countries like Italy and France openly defying spending cuts, while Germany's reluctance to break from balanced budgets and increase investment spending exacerbates the contracting economy.
Germany's economy, the largest in the EU, is expected to contract by 0.6% this year due to a slowdown in exports and years of under-investment in infrastructure and technology, posing long-term challenges for growth and requiring significant investment and reforms to address them.
Central Europe's economies, with their cost competitive manufacturing base and clean-burning power systems, are positioned for greater prominence as companies consider shifting production to the region due to lower operating costs and cleaner power sources compared to Germany.
Germany needs structural reforms to address the current global economic challenges and stimulate growth, according to IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva. She highlights the need for reforms in the automobile sector, which is crucial for increasing productivity. Georgieva also mentions that although the global economy has shown resilience, the recovery remains slow and uneven, with emerging markets and low-income countries lagging behind.
Germany is projected to experience a deeper recession than previously forecasted, with its economy expected to contract by 0.5% this year due to inflation, manufacturing decline, weakness in interest-rate-sensitive sectors, and slower trading-partner demand, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
Germany's government expects the country's economy to shrink by 0.4% this year due to the energy price crisis and global economic weakness, contrasting the previous forecast of 0.4% growth.
Germany has revised its economic forecast for 2023, projecting a 0.4% decline in GDP due to the energy price crisis, inflation concerns, and weakening global economic partners, such as China.
Germany faces a contraction in economic growth, with the economy expected to shrink by 0.4 percent in 2023, making it the only major world economy to post negative growth figures this year, due to factors including the energy price crisis and weakening global economic partners.