1. Home
  2. >
  3. Stock Markets 🤑
Posted

‘Overly data-dependent’ — how the Fed and the markets keep getting it wrong

  • Federal Reserve officials emphasize interest rate decisions will be data-dependent, avoiding commitments. Other central banks also taking data-dependent approach.

  • Economic data often unreliable. Statistics like jobs reports and GDP undergo substantial revisions over time.

  • Dangers of overly data-dependent policy. Fed kept rates too low early 2000s due to low inflation estimates, possibly fueling housing bubble.

  • Key parameters like r-star, u-star, potential GDP unobservable and time-varying. Structural shifts play havoc.

  • Fed's poor forecasting record. Should acknowledge uncertainty in data. Widen inflation target range, add financial stability focus to ease volatility.

thehill.com
Relevant topic timeline:
Central banks are facing significant challenges due to shifts in the global economy, including changes in the labor market, energy transition, and geopolitical division, and must adapt their policymaking frameworks to ensure stability in the face of uncertainty, according to Christine Lagarde, President of the European Central Bank.
Central bankers are uncertain if they have raised interest rates enough, prompting concerns about the effectiveness of their monetary policies.
The strong U.S. economic growth and potential rate hikes by the Federal Reserve could pose global risks, potentially leading to a significant tightening of global financial conditions and affecting emerging markets and the rest of the world.
The outlook for the euro area remains uncertain as economic activity has slowed and indicators suggest weakness ahead, but the labor market remains resilient; a restrictive monetary policy is critical for bringing inflation back to the 2% target in a timely manner, and a data-dependent and robust approach to monetary policy is warranted due to the high level of uncertainty.
Federal Reserve Governor Christopher Waller acknowledges that recent strong economic data will allow the central bank to proceed cautiously with potential interest rate hikes as it assesses whether inflation is under control.
Bank of America warns that the US economy still faces the risk of a "hard landing" due to rising oil prices, a strong dollar, and potential interest rate hikes by the Federal Reserve, contrasting with the optimistic outlook of other Wall Street banks.
The risk of overestimating the economy is now a real possibility as economic data continues to defy recessionary predictions, but the lagging production side of the economic equation and the deviation between GDP and Gross Domestic Income (GDI) suggest increased risk to the optimistic outlook and a potential recessionary warning.
Uncertainty in various sectors, including potential strikes, government shutdowns, geopolitical tensions, and the question of future Federal Reserve interest rate hikes, is causing markets to lack conviction, but this week's inflation readings could provide direction for the markets. If inflation comes in below expectations, it may signal that the Fed will not hike rates further, while stronger-than-expected inflation could lead to more rate hikes and market volatility. Additionally, increasing energy prices and the potential strike by the United Auto Workers union add to the uncertainty.
The European Central Bank's handling of monetary policy under Christine Lagarde, including unnecessary interest rate hikes, risks pushing the Eurozone into a recession.
The Federal Reserve's uncertainty about 2024 is causing concern for the markets.
The U.S. economy is facing uncertainty and conflicting estimates, with regional Fed estimates showing significant divergence and risks of economic contraction or slow growth, while factors such as health insurance costs, wage growth, home prices, and rising gas and commodity prices could potentially cause inflation to rebound. Moreover, there are still risks and challenges ahead, making declarations of victory premature, according to Larry Summers.
Overall inflation has moderated recently in the United States and euro area, but core inflation remains sticky, creating a challenge for central banks trying to meet their inflation targets. Financial conditions have eased, complicating the fight against inflation by preventing a slowdown in aggregate demand. The combination of loose financial conditions and a monetary policy tightening cycle may have dulled the effectiveness of monetary policy. There are risks of a repricing of risk assets and potential vulnerabilities in the financial sector, emphasizing the need for central banks to remain determined in their fight against inflation.
The fear of the lag effects of aggressive monetary policy tightening is growing among investors, as concerns about the impact on the economy and stocks intensify, with some top investors warning of a potential recession and advising caution in the current market environment.