1. Home
  2. >
  3. Economy 🏛️
Posted

China Sees $49 Billion in Capital Outflow in August Amid Economic Struggles

  • China suffered a capital outflow of $49 billion in August, the largest since 2015, as the economy stumbles.

  • Of that, $29 billion exited securities like stocks and bonds, including a record $12 billion in stock selloffs.

  • August saw a $16.8 billion deficit in direct foreign investment, the deepest since 2016.

  • Weak exports and attraction of US yields pushed the yuan to 16-month lows in September.

  • Capital flight may continue as GDP growth expectations dim and tourism/services remain depressed.

businessinsider.com
Relevant topic timeline:
### Summary The upcoming Jackson Hole Symposium is expected to deliver a hawkish but cautious message from the Fed chair, with a focus on the strong US economy, resilient US consumer, and persistent inflation. ### Facts - 📉 Last year, the markets experienced a major selloff following the Fed chair's unexpectedly hawkish speech at Jackson Hole. - 💪 This year, the markets are pessimistic due to the strong US economic numbers, including a predicted 5.8% growth for Q3. - 🎙️ The Fed chair will likely discuss the possibility of a November rate hike but may roil the markets if he mentions further rate hikes. - 🌐 The slowdown of China's economy is a concern as it is the second-largest economy globally, and reduced outlooks for Chinese GDP are being reported by major institutions. - 💼 China's high levels of local government debt and shadow banking pose a risk of contagion, with real estate and shadow bank crises being the main focus. - 📉 A selloff in China could lead to an emerging market selloff, but India may experience a heavier selloff due to the significant amount of money investors have made there. - 🌍 The opaque nature of China's government and lack of data make it challenging to fully understand the depth of the country's economic issues.
### Summary India's finance secretary, T.V. Somanathan, believes that the slowing Chinese economy will have limited impact on India's economy, and the government will continue with its capital expenditure push. ### Facts - 📉 The Chinese economy is experiencing a slowdown, with retail sales, industrial output, and investment data coming in lower than expected. - 📉 Five major brokerages have reduced their growth forecasts for China this year. - 🇮🇳 The finance secretary of India, T.V. Somanathan, stated that China's slowdown would have little negative effect on India due to the large trade deficit between the two countries. - 🇮🇳 Somanathan assured that the government will not exceed the budget estimate of 5.9% of GDP for fiscal deficit. - 🇮🇳 The government will continue its capital expenditure push as part of its growth strategy, with capital expenditure being a priority. - 🇮🇳 There are no plans to shift from capital expenditure to revenue expenditure despite the impending general elections in 2024. - 🇮🇳 The government expects robust capital spending in the April-September period, with anticipated offtake in the 50-60% range. - 🛠️ The government's move to impose import restrictions on laptops and tablets is due to limited policy instruments available under World Trade Organization rules. - 🛠️ Starting November 1, imports of laptops and tablets will require a license, as they fall under the high-tech ITA-1 products category. (Source: The Economic Times)
### Summary Ray Dalio, a renowned investor, believes that China's struggling economy needs a significant debt restructuring, despite economists stating that Beijing won't intervene to support the failing property sector. ### Facts - Ray Dalio currently has approximately $3 billion invested in Chinese businesses. - China's struggling property sector, plagued by failing property giants and sinking house prices, is causing concerns about contagion in other industries. - Beijing is unlikely to step in and prop up developers, even though the sector is described as the "single most important" industry on a global scale. - China's debt has nearly doubled over the past five years, reaching about 66 trillion yuan ($9.3 trillion), which is more than half the country's annual economic output. - Dalio suggests that China should undertake a massive debt restructuring, similar to what Zhu Rongji orchestrated in the late 1990s but on a larger scale. - Dalio believes that China's restructuring would be easier than other countries' due to the majority of debt being held in the country's own currency. - The two levers to facilitate the "beautiful deleveraging" process in China are deflationary defaults and restructurings, combined with the inflationary measure of printing money. - Other countries, such as Japan, the United States, and Europe, will also need to deleverage eventually, but Dalio thinks China should take the first step. - China is currently facing various alarming issues, including intervention in the currency markets, soaring youth joblessness, and a drop in land sales. - China Evergrande, a major property developer, has filed for bankruptcy protection, and China's largest developer, Country Garden, is on the verge of default.
### Summary The Chinese economy has slipped into deflationary mode, with retail sales, industrial production, and exports all missing forecasts. Shrinking domestic demand and a debt-fueled housing crisis are the main causes behind this slowdown. ### Facts - 📉 Retail sales in July grew by 2.5% year-on-year, compared to 3.1% in June. - 🏭 Value-added industrial output expanded by 3.7% y-o-y, slowing from 4.4% growth in June. - 📉 China's exports fell by 14.5% in July compared to the previous year, and imports dropped 12.4%. - 💼 Overall unemployment rate rose to 5.3% in July, with youth unemployment at a record 21.3% in June. - 📉 Consumer Price Index-based inflation dropped to (-)0.3%, indicating a deflationary situation. - 🏢 China's debt is estimated at 282% of GDP, higher than that of the US. ### Causes of the slowdown - The debt-fueled housing sector collapse, which contributes to 30% of China's GDP. - Stringent zero-Covid strategy and lockdown measures that stifled the domestic economy and disrupted global supply chains. - Geopolitical tensions and crackdowns on the tech sector, resulting in revenue losses and job cuts. ### Reaction of global markets - The S&P 500 fell 1.2% following the grim Chinese data. - US Treasury Secretary warns China's slowing economy is a risk factor for the US economy. - Japanese stocks and the Indian Nifty were also impacted. - China's central bank cut its benchmark lending rate, but investors were hoping for more significant stimulus measures. ### Global market concerns - China's struggle to achieve the 5% growth target may impact global demand. - China is the world's largest manufacturing economy and consumer of key commodities. - A slowdown in China could affect global growth, with the IMF's forecast of 35% growth contribution by China seeming unlikely. ### Impact on India - India's aim to compete with China in the global supply chain could benefit if Chinese exports decline. - However, if China cuts back on commodity production due to slowing domestic demand, it may push commodity prices higher.
### Summary The global economy is showing signs of decoupling, with the US economy remaining strong and China's economy disappointing at the margin. The recent data suggests that the US economy is resilient, with consumption and other indicators pointing in a positive direction. However, there are concerns about the bear steepening of the US curve and the repricing of the long end of the curve. In contrast, China's economy continues to struggle, with weak data and monetary policy easing. Japan has surprised with positive data, but there are questions about whether the current inflation shift will lead to tighter monetary policy. Overall, there are concerns about a potential global economic recession and its impact on various economies. ### Facts - 💰 Despite the decoupling of the US and China economies, concerns remain about the negative impact of a China slowdown on global growth. - 💹 Recent data show that the US economy, particularly consumption, remains resilient. - 🔒 The bear steepening of the US curve and the repricing of the long end of the curve are causing concerns. - 🇨🇳 In China, weak data on consumption and investment and declining house prices continue to affect the economy. The PBoC has eased monetary policy. - 🇯🇵 Japan's 2Q data surprised with strong export growth, but there are concerns about the impact of a potential inflation shift on global yields. - 🌍 The global economy is at risk of recession, with concerns about the impact on emerging market economies and the US economy.
### Summary Growing concerns about global economic growth and uncertainties in monetary policy have led to turbulence in financial markets, with rising bond yields and a decline in equity markets. Key factors affecting growth include interest rates, bond yields, and access to funds, which may result in a credit crunch and a more risk-averse environment in capital markets. China's shift towards self-sufficiency, combined with a more prudent policy environment, slower population growth, and trade sanctions, will lead to slower and more erratic growth in the country. Although there are near-term concerns, the longer-term outlook for global growth remains positive. ### Facts - Global economic growth is a concern, reflected in rising bond yields and a decline in equity markets. - Policymakers, particularly in the US, are worried about overtightening monetary policy. - Western economies, including the UK, have proven resilient despite expectations of a recession. - Lower inflation will boost spending power, but growth will depend on where interest rates and bond yields settle. - Businesses face challenges in raising funds due to a credit crunch, tough lending conditions, and a risk-averse capital market environment. - The International Monetary Fund forecasts global growth to slow from 3.5% last year to 3% this year and next, with Asia being a major driver. - Concerns about deflation in China exist, but low inflation is more likely. - China's shift towards self-sufficiency in response to trade wars has coincided with a more prudent policy environment and the need to curb inflation and manage debt overhang. - A shrinking population and structural changes in China will result in slower and more erratic growth. - Private sector activity remains strong in Asia, and Japan's economy is experiencing an economic rebound. - Western economies previously experienced a prolonged period of cheap money, which led to imbalances and misallocation of capital. - Prudent monetary policy in some emerging economies provides more room to act in response to economic weakness. - Concerns exist regarding rising policy rates in the US, UK, and euro area and the tightening of central banks' balance sheets. - The definition of a risk-free asset is being questioned, as government bonds, previously considered safe, have witnessed negative total returns. - There has been a rise in shadow banking and non-bank financial institutions, with collateral in the form of government bonds playing a crucial role. Overall, the focus is shifting from inflation to growth, and future policy rates may need to settle at a high level. High levels of public and private debt globally limit policy maneuverability and expose individuals and firms to higher interest rates.
### Summary The People's Bank of China is expected to cut interest rates in order to calm the nervousness and concern sweeping through the country's financial markets. ### Facts - 🔍 The People's Bank of China is expected to cut interest rates on Monday. - 🔒 The Chinese central bank may have to make a big move in order to soothe nervousness in the financial markets. - 🏦 The Bank of Korea and Bank Indonesia are expected to keep interest rates on hold on Thursday. - 💼 The Chinese central bank's decision and wider developments around China's markets and economy will dominate investors' thinking this week. - 💰 The U.S. Federal Reserve's annual Jackson Hole Symposium and the BRICS summit in South Africa will also be closely watched. - 📉 Chinese economists are slashing their GDP growth forecasts due to deflation, slumping trade activity, and an imploding property sector. - 💣 The real estate crisis poses a threat to growth and raises questions about the strength of the shadow banking system. - 📉 Chinese blue chip stocks are down 6% in the last two weeks, and financial conditions are tightest since December. - 🌍 Global markets are experiencing volatility, with a surging dollar, rising U.S. Treasury yields, and stock markets experiencing vertigo. - 📈 Key developments to watch on Monday include the China interest rate decision, Thailand GDP for Q2, and Hong Kong inflation for July.
### Summary The People's Bank of China is expected to cut interest rates, but may need to take a larger action to calm the uncertainty in the market. Other factors like the US Federal Reserve's Jackson Hole Symposium and the BRICS summit will also impact investor sentiment. ### Facts - 💰 The People's Bank of China is expected to cut interest rates to soothe market concerns. - 💼 Bank of Korea and Bank Indonesia are expected to keep interest rates on hold this week. - 🌍 The US Federal Reserve's Jackson Hole Symposium and the BRICS summit will affect investor thinking. - 📉 Chinese policymakers' conservative nature may result in more aggressive moves in the interest rate cut. - 🔒 The currency is already weak and vulnerable, posing a risk to further cuts. - 📉 Economists are lowering Chinese GDP growth forecasts, doubting the country will achieve its 2023 goal. - 🏘️ The real estate crisis and the scale of indebtedness raise questions about the stability of the shadow banking system. - 🔧 Beijing is taking steps to boost confidence, but measures seem insufficient. - 📉 Chinese blue chip stocks have decreased by 6% in the last two weeks. - 🌐 Global markets are facing a deteriorating backdrop, with the dollar surging, US Treasury yields rising, and stock markets experiencing instability. - 🗓️ Key developments on Monday include China's interest rate decision, Thailand's Q2 GDP, and Hong Kong's July inflation.
### Summary Asian stocks were mixed as traders awaited the Federal Reserve's summer conference to determine if more interest rate hikes are necessary to deal with inflation. ### Facts - 📉 Shanghai and Hong Kong stocks retreated, while Tokyo and Seoul stocks advanced. - 📉 The Hang Seng in Hong Kong lost 1.1%. - 📈 The Nikkei 225 in Tokyo advanced 0.6%. - 📈 The Kospi in Seoul gained 0.6%. - 📊 The S&P 500 index ended the week lower by 0.1%. - 💵 Some investors are shifting money to bonds as higher interest rates make their payout bigger and less risky. - 💹 Tech and other high-growth stocks are some of the biggest losers due to higher rates. - 📉 Ross Stores jumped 5% after reporting stronger-than-expected results, while Estee Lauder fell 3.3% despite reporting stronger profit and revenue than expected. - ⛽ Benchmark U.S. crude gained 73 cents to $81.39 per barrel, while Brent crude reached $85.55 per barrel. - 💲 The dollar slightly edged up to 145.35 yen, while the euro rose to $1.0882. (Source: AP News)
### Summary China has only made a small trim to its benchmark lending rate, disappointing analysts and putting pressure on Chinese blue-chips and the yuan. However, Beijing seems unlikely to launch fiscal stimulus to boost the economy. Meanwhile, the United States has a large budget deficit, which may explain the strong GDP growth. ### Facts - 💼 China cuts one-year benchmark lending rate by 10 basis points, surprising analysts who expected bigger cuts. - 💼 Pressure on Chinese blue-chips and yuan continues despite attempts by the People's Bank of China (PBOC) to support it. - 💼 Western investors expect Beijing to provide fiscal stimulus, but there are no signs of compliance from authorities. - 💼 China's securities regulator unveils measures to boost investor confidence, with several companies announcing plans to buy their own shares. - 💼 PBOC announces coordination of financial support to resolve local government debt issues and encourages banks to lend more. - 💼 Chinese shares stabilize after initial decline, Nikkei and Aussie recover. - 💼 United States has a large budget deficit, running at an annual $1.6 trillion, potentially driving unexpected GDP growth. - 💼 Fed Chair Jerome Powell faces a messaging challenge at the Jackson Hole meeting this week regarding strong GDP growth and inflation decline. - 💼 Key developments that could influence markets on Monday include a joint press conference of Finance Ministers and German producer price data for July.
China's economy is facing a downward spiral due to a crisis in the debt-laden property sector, prompting seven city banks to reduce their growth forecasts for the country; concerns include falling into deflation, high unemployment rates, and the need for more proactive government support.
China's major state-owned banks are actively acquiring the offshore yuan as the currency faces increasing pressure from a deteriorating economy and strain in the property sector, effectively raising the cost of shorting the currency and stabilizing its value.
China's big five state-owned banks are expected to see a decline in revenue and narrower net interest margins as they face challenges such as low credit demand and pressure to support the economy amid a debt crisis in the property sector.
China's economy is at risk of entering a debt-deflation loop, similar to Japan's in the 1990s, but this can be avoided if policymakers keep interest rates below a crucial level to stimulate economic growth.
China's regulators are struggling to attract global funds to invest in the country's stocks due to a lack of strong stimulus measures to support growth, resulting in a slump in the MSCI China Index and significant outflows from the mainland market.
China's economic slowdown is causing alarm worldwide, with countries experiencing a slump in trade, falling commodity prices, and a decrease in Chinese demand for goods and services, while global investors are pulling billions of dollars from China's stock markets and cutting their targets for Chinese equities.
China's economy is struggling due to an imbalance between investments and consumption, resulting in increased debt and limited household spending, and without a shift towards consumption and increased policy measures, the economic slowdown may have profound consequences for China and the world.
China's central bank will cut the amount of foreign exchange reserves required for financial institutions, in an effort to slow the decline of the yuan.
The prospect of a prolonged economic slump in China poses a serious threat to global growth, potentially changing fundamental aspects of the global economy, affecting debt markets and supply chains, and impacting emerging markets and the United States.
China's economy is showing signs of slowing down, including a decrease in GDP growth rate, declining exports, deflationary consumer price index, high youth unemployment, a weakening yuan, and a decrease in new loans, which could have global implications.
China's economy risks falling into a vicious cycle of debt and deflation, but economist Shang-Jin Wei suggests that launching an aggressive bond-buying campaign and allowing the yuan to lose value may be necessary to avoid this trap.
China's imports and exports experienced a monthly decline in August, with exports falling by 8.8% and imports falling by 7.3%, indicating ongoing challenges despite some slight improvement.
The onshore yuan dropped to a 16-year low against the dollar, reflecting growing pessimism towards China's economy and financial markets.
China's total import and export value in the first 8 months of this year slightly decreased by 0.1 percent compared to the previous year, but exports have continued to grow and the global market share remains stable, highlighting the overall stability of China's foreign trade operations.
China is showing signs of a balance-sheet recession similar to Japan's, with accumulating debt and falling house prices, but there are key differences that suggest it may not face the same fate. State-owned enterprises and property developers account for much of China's debt, and households have low debt relative to their assets. However, the Chinese government's reluctance to increase spending could prolong the recession.
Chinese stocks have passed the worst of the selling pressure and are still attractive to investors due to their cheap valuation and potential for growth, according to CLSA. However, Beijing needs to address concerns and risks in the economy. The MSCI China Index has fallen this year, but a pause in the Federal Reserve's tightening policy is expected to reverse market pessimism.
The struggling real estate sector in China, due to a current crisis and government regulations, is impacting consumer spending and causing Chinese tourists to be slow in returning to international travel. As Chinese homeowners prioritize savings and cut back on spending, global tourism destinations are experiencing a decline in Chinese visitors, resulting in a forecasted decrease of nearly 70% in China's outbound travel spending this year.
Chinese stocks experienced the largest monthly outflow in a year, with foreign investors withdrawing $15.5 billion from emerging market portfolios in August, driven by concerns over China's economic growth.
China's offshore yuan weakened after the country's central bank announced a cut in banks' reserve requirement ratio, which aims to support the economy but could further worsen the decline of the yuan.
China's currency, the yuan, has depreciated over 8% against the dollar as the Chinese economy grows less than expected, making it harder to reach its growth target of 5% for 2023, and worries about the economy have intensified due to issues in the real estate sector and financial health of local governments, causing concerns about the future of the yuan which may experience a slow but steady depreciation in the face of a weak dollar and a desire to maintain a trade surplus.
China's macroeconomic challenges, including deflationary pressures, yuan depreciation, and a struggling property sector, could have broader implications beyond its borders, impacting global metal exporters, trade deals, and global inflation; however, investing in China's stocks may offer compelling valuations despite the current downturn.
China is unlikely to devalue its currency, the yuan, despite concerns that it could do so to boost exports, as such a move would risk intensifying capital flight and tightening financial conditions, according to the Institute of International Finance. Instead, the focus will be on domestic easing measures to maintain steady growth, although there is the challenge of balancing the yuan's stability against the strengthening US dollar and other major currencies.
A retreat of funds from Chinese stocks and bonds is diminishing China's global market influence and accelerating its decoupling from the rest of the world, due to economic concerns, tensions with the West, and a property market crisis.
China is experiencing a significant outflow of capital, putting pressure on the yuan and raising concerns for authorities as the currency weakens and financial markets become destabilized.
Bitcoin could experience significant inflows from China in the coming months due to a weakening Chinese yuan and increasing capital flight, with Chinese investors turning to Bitcoin as a familiar investment in times of economic uncertainty, according to experts. The recent data shows that China's capital outflow reached its highest level since 2015 in August, potentially putting further pressure on the yuan. While Chinese capital controls may limit investment options, cryptocurrency, particularly Bitcoin, is seen as a viable alternative. However, analysts caution that the impact of Chinese capital flight on Bitcoin may not be as significant as it was in 2017 due to changes in regulations and crackdowns on certain practices.
Investors withdrew $19 billion from the stock market, the highest outflow of the year, as rising bond yields and uncertainty about interest rates raised concerns of a market bubble, according to Bank of America, warning that the situation could lead to a difficult 2024.
The slow recovery of foreign tourism in China due to visa obstacles and fears of the country is hindering the nation's economy and its ability to attract foreign investment.
China's foreign exchange reserves, the world's largest, fell by $45 billion in September, more than expected, as the value of the yuan dropped against the strengthening US dollar.
Asian shares mostly fell amid concerns about the U.S. banking system and Chinese economic growth, with Japan's Nikkei 225 down 0.2% and Hong Kong's Hang Seng down 0.4%, while China's export data showed the sharpest decline in three years. Bank stocks in the U.S. also fell after Moody's cut credit ratings for 10 smaller and midsized banks, citing concerns about their financial strength in light of higher interest rates and the work-from-home trend. The Federal Reserve's efforts to combat inflation by raising interest rates have led to a slowdown in the economy and hit banks hard.
China's asset-backed securities market, which has seen significant growth in recent years, may pose risks due to the potential for fraud and the interdependencies among banks. The complex nature of these financial instruments, as demonstrated during the global financial crisis, could lead to a domino effect and have negative implications for China's economy.
China's weak economic recovery and the risks associated with its property crisis are likely to impact Asia's economic prospects, according to the International Monetary Fund (IMF), leading to a cloudier outlook for the region and potential spillover effects on commodity-exporting countries with close trade links to China. The IMF revised its growth estimate for Asia down to 4.2% for 2024, and emphasized the need for central banks in the region to exercise caution in cutting interest rates due to sticky core inflation and other global factors such as the Middle East conflict. Additionally, the IMF warned that Japan's normalization of monetary policy could have significant global implications.
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) warns that China's weak economic recovery and the risk of a prolonged property crisis could negatively impact Asian economies, especially those that export raw materials to China, while the strength of the U.S. economy provides less support to the region due to its service industry-focused growth. Additionally, the IMF highlights the potential impact of Japanese financial policy changes on other countries, particularly if further actions are taken by the Bank of Japan.