1. Home
  2. >
  3. Economy 🏛️
Posted

China Faces Worst Capital Flight in Years, Weakening Yuan and Economy

  • China witnessing biggest capital flight in years, worsening yuan pressure
  • $49B outflow from capital account in August, largest since December 2015
  • Outflows spurred by sputtering economic growth, widening interest rate gap with US
  • Yuan hit 16-year low amid capital flight, risking further destabilization
  • Trend looks hard to reverse given monetary policy divergence and economic woes
yahoo.com
Relevant topic timeline:
### Summary The upcoming Jackson Hole Symposium is expected to deliver a hawkish but cautious message from the Fed chair, with a focus on the strong US economy, resilient US consumer, and persistent inflation. ### Facts - 📉 Last year, the markets experienced a major selloff following the Fed chair's unexpectedly hawkish speech at Jackson Hole. - 💪 This year, the markets are pessimistic due to the strong US economic numbers, including a predicted 5.8% growth for Q3. - 🎙️ The Fed chair will likely discuss the possibility of a November rate hike but may roil the markets if he mentions further rate hikes. - 🌐 The slowdown of China's economy is a concern as it is the second-largest economy globally, and reduced outlooks for Chinese GDP are being reported by major institutions. - 💼 China's high levels of local government debt and shadow banking pose a risk of contagion, with real estate and shadow bank crises being the main focus. - 📉 A selloff in China could lead to an emerging market selloff, but India may experience a heavier selloff due to the significant amount of money investors have made there. - 🌍 The opaque nature of China's government and lack of data make it challenging to fully understand the depth of the country's economic issues.
### Summary Ray Dalio, a renowned investor, believes that China's struggling economy needs a significant debt restructuring, despite economists stating that Beijing won't intervene to support the failing property sector. ### Facts - Ray Dalio currently has approximately $3 billion invested in Chinese businesses. - China's struggling property sector, plagued by failing property giants and sinking house prices, is causing concerns about contagion in other industries. - Beijing is unlikely to step in and prop up developers, even though the sector is described as the "single most important" industry on a global scale. - China's debt has nearly doubled over the past five years, reaching about 66 trillion yuan ($9.3 trillion), which is more than half the country's annual economic output. - Dalio suggests that China should undertake a massive debt restructuring, similar to what Zhu Rongji orchestrated in the late 1990s but on a larger scale. - Dalio believes that China's restructuring would be easier than other countries' due to the majority of debt being held in the country's own currency. - The two levers to facilitate the "beautiful deleveraging" process in China are deflationary defaults and restructurings, combined with the inflationary measure of printing money. - Other countries, such as Japan, the United States, and Europe, will also need to deleverage eventually, but Dalio thinks China should take the first step. - China is currently facing various alarming issues, including intervention in the currency markets, soaring youth joblessness, and a drop in land sales. - China Evergrande, a major property developer, has filed for bankruptcy protection, and China's largest developer, Country Garden, is on the verge of default.
### Summary Growing concerns about global economic growth and uncertainties in monetary policy have led to turbulence in financial markets, with rising bond yields and a decline in equity markets. Key factors affecting growth include interest rates, bond yields, and access to funds, which may result in a credit crunch and a more risk-averse environment in capital markets. China's shift towards self-sufficiency, combined with a more prudent policy environment, slower population growth, and trade sanctions, will lead to slower and more erratic growth in the country. Although there are near-term concerns, the longer-term outlook for global growth remains positive. ### Facts - Global economic growth is a concern, reflected in rising bond yields and a decline in equity markets. - Policymakers, particularly in the US, are worried about overtightening monetary policy. - Western economies, including the UK, have proven resilient despite expectations of a recession. - Lower inflation will boost spending power, but growth will depend on where interest rates and bond yields settle. - Businesses face challenges in raising funds due to a credit crunch, tough lending conditions, and a risk-averse capital market environment. - The International Monetary Fund forecasts global growth to slow from 3.5% last year to 3% this year and next, with Asia being a major driver. - Concerns about deflation in China exist, but low inflation is more likely. - China's shift towards self-sufficiency in response to trade wars has coincided with a more prudent policy environment and the need to curb inflation and manage debt overhang. - A shrinking population and structural changes in China will result in slower and more erratic growth. - Private sector activity remains strong in Asia, and Japan's economy is experiencing an economic rebound. - Western economies previously experienced a prolonged period of cheap money, which led to imbalances and misallocation of capital. - Prudent monetary policy in some emerging economies provides more room to act in response to economic weakness. - Concerns exist regarding rising policy rates in the US, UK, and euro area and the tightening of central banks' balance sheets. - The definition of a risk-free asset is being questioned, as government bonds, previously considered safe, have witnessed negative total returns. - There has been a rise in shadow banking and non-bank financial institutions, with collateral in the form of government bonds playing a crucial role. Overall, the focus is shifting from inflation to growth, and future policy rates may need to settle at a high level. High levels of public and private debt globally limit policy maneuverability and expose individuals and firms to higher interest rates.
China's real estate crisis, caused by a crackdown on risky behavior by home builders and a subsequent housing slowdown, is spreading to the broader economy, leading to sinking sales, disappearing jobs, and a decline in consumer confidence, business investment, and stock markets.
China is facing a severe economic downturn, with record youth unemployment, a slumping housing market, stagnant spending, and deflation, which has led to a sense of despair and reluctance to spend among consumers and business owners, potentially fueling a dangerous cycle.
China's major state-owned banks are actively acquiring offshore yuan liquidity, raising the cost of shorting the Chinese currency and potentially stabilizing the yuan.
The Chinese bond market is experiencing a significant shift due to concerns over China's economic growth prospects, including a bursting property bubble and lack of government stimulus, leading to potential capital flight and pressure on the yuan, which could result in increased selling of US Treasuries by Chinese banks and a rethink of global growth expectations.
As China's economic crisis unfolds, it is becoming apparent that the immense debt accumulated in building infrastructure projects, coupled with high unemployment and personal decisions made by Xi Jinping, could pose a serious threat to the regime's stability and potentially lead to a post-Communist China.
China's regulators are struggling to attract global funds to invest in the country's stocks due to a lack of strong stimulus measures to support growth, resulting in a slump in the MSCI China Index and significant outflows from the mainland market.
China's economic struggles, including a real estate slump, high youth unemployment, and rising tensions with the West, could lead to deflation and sluggish growth, potentially impacting the global economy and causing a "new normal" of slower GDP growth worldwide.
China's economic slowdown is causing alarm across the world, as it is expected to have a negative impact on global economic growth, leading to reduced imports and trade, falling commodity prices, a deflationary effect on global goods prices, and a decline in tourism and luxury spending.
Global investors are skeptical of China's ability to stabilize its financial markets, with many predicting that economic pressures will cause the offshore exchange rate of the yuan to reach record lows.
China is facing increasing financial stress as a property giant seeks to avoid default and a state-run bad debt manager experiences a bond slump, contributing to concerns about the country's economy.
China's currency, the yuan, is at its lowest level against the dollar since the 2008 financial crash, which raises concerns about the country's economic stability and its ability to boost domestic consumption.
The prospect of a prolonged economic slump in China poses a serious threat to global growth, potentially changing fundamental aspects of the global economy, affecting debt markets and supply chains, and impacting emerging markets and the United States.
China's economy is showing signs of slowing down, including a decrease in GDP growth rate, declining exports, deflationary consumer price index, high youth unemployment, a weakening yuan, and a decrease in new loans, which could have global implications.
China's yuan finished the domestic session on Friday at its weakest since the global financial crisis, impacted by capital outflow pressures and a growing yield gap with other major economies, leading to expectations of further selling pressure in the near term but likely measured losses.
Chinese stocks have passed the worst of the selling pressure and are still attractive to investors due to their cheap valuation and potential for growth, according to CLSA. However, Beijing needs to address concerns and risks in the economy. The MSCI China Index has fallen this year, but a pause in the Federal Reserve's tightening policy is expected to reverse market pessimism.
China's credit demand improved, deflationary pressures eased, and the yuan rallied, indicating signs of stabilization in the economy and financial markets after a sharp downturn.
Chinese stocks experienced their largest monthly outflow in August, as waning interest from global investors was driven by negative sentiment over the country's economic outlook and concerns over regulatory uncertainty and strained international relations. Foreign direct investment (FDI) inflows to China also contracted, with China's share of FDI inflows among emerging markets predicted to decline to less than 30% by 2027.
China's offshore yuan weakened after the country's central bank announced a cut in banks' reserve requirement ratio, which aims to support the economy but could further worsen the decline of the yuan.
Local governments in China are facing an urgent liquidity crisis as their deteriorating financial health and mounting debt pose risks of defaults, with doubts about the central government's ability to effectively resolve the situation and concerns over the consequences of curbing local government borrowing.
China's currency, the yuan, has depreciated over 8% against the dollar as the Chinese economy grows less than expected, making it harder to reach its growth target of 5% for 2023, and worries about the economy have intensified due to issues in the real estate sector and financial health of local governments, causing concerns about the future of the yuan which may experience a slow but steady depreciation in the face of a weak dollar and a desire to maintain a trade surplus.
China's macroeconomic challenges, including deflationary pressures, yuan depreciation, and a struggling property sector, could have broader implications beyond its borders, impacting global metal exporters, trade deals, and global inflation; however, investing in China's stocks may offer compelling valuations despite the current downturn.
China is unlikely to devalue its currency, the yuan, despite concerns that it could do so to boost exports, as such a move would risk intensifying capital flight and tightening financial conditions, according to the Institute of International Finance. Instead, the focus will be on domestic easing measures to maintain steady growth, although there is the challenge of balancing the yuan's stability against the strengthening US dollar and other major currencies.
A retreat of funds from Chinese stocks and bonds is diminishing China's global market influence and accelerating its decoupling from the rest of the world, due to economic concerns, tensions with the West, and a property market crisis.
China's credit is expanding rapidly, with total social financing increasing by over 3 trillion yuan in August, mainly driven by government financing, indicating positive signs of economic stabilization and recovery from the slump in the second quarter. Additionally, recent policy measures, particularly in fiscal and property sectors, are expected to further stimulate the economy.
China experienced its largest capital outflow since 2015, with $49 billion leaving the country, as economic concerns prompt investors to withdraw; of this, $29 billion was withdrawn from securities investments, including bonds. The outflow was compounded by a record-high $12 billion in mainland-listed stocks being dumped by foreign investors and a $16.8 billion deficit in direct investment, the largest since 2016. The decline in the capital account was exacerbated by the tourism season, with outbound travel negatively impacting the services sector, while inbound travel remained suppressed, causing a continued deficit in the services trade. Efforts by Beijing, such as reducing the foreign currency reserves held by banks, have aimed to support the yuan but have been unable to prevent a significant decline in the offshore yuan. Weak exports and the allure of US yields have also contributed to the yuan's decline, further complicating China's capital flight situation, as doubts about the country's ability to achieve its 5% GDP target for the year grow.
Bitcoin could experience significant inflows from China in the coming months due to a weakening Chinese yuan and increasing capital flight, with Chinese investors turning to Bitcoin as a familiar investment in times of economic uncertainty, according to experts. The recent data shows that China's capital outflow reached its highest level since 2015 in August, potentially putting further pressure on the yuan. While Chinese capital controls may limit investment options, cryptocurrency, particularly Bitcoin, is seen as a viable alternative. However, analysts caution that the impact of Chinese capital flight on Bitcoin may not be as significant as it was in 2017 due to changes in regulations and crackdowns on certain practices.
Concerns over a possible U.S. government shutdown, rising oil prices, and a heavy schedule of Treasury debt sales are adding pressure to the markets, along with the ongoing property crisis in China and the effects of last week's hawkish Federal Reserve projections.
China's economic growth appears to be slowing down, with issues such as an aging population and a collapsing housing sector leading to speculation that the country's economic miracle may be coming to an end, while its diplomatic strategies have also caused strain on international relationships.
China's financial system and economy are facing significant risks, resembling a "Minsky moment," as it doubles down on excessive debt, invests in nonproductive enterprises, experiences weak economic growth, and faces internal unrest and military aggression, which could have global implications.
China's economy is on the brink of a potential "apocalyptic" collapse that could have disastrous effects on global stock markets, as the country's economic indicators continue to plummet and financial experts warn of an imminent crash.
China's property market blowup, which has led to major developers struggling and low housing sales, may not necessarily result in a financial crisis due to the unique characteristics of China's housing market and Beijing's control over the financial system, but it is expected to cause significant damage to bank balance sheets and potentially lead to widespread financial turbulence if support is not provided to local governments and small lenders.
Tensions between the West and China are rising, impacting global markets by increasing inflation and interest rates, shifting supply chains, creating opportunities for emerging nations and tech giants, and affecting industries such as manufacturing, infrastructure, luxury goods, and technology. Investors are split on how to approach the Chinese market amidst these tensions.
Investors tend to overlook the gradual impact of the decoupling between China and the world's two largest economies while focusing on the risk of a potential invasion of Taiwan.
China's economy is facing uncertainties due to concerns about the property crisis, a lack of confidence, and a slowdown in year-on-year GDP growth, which is expected to be below Beijing's target of around 5%.
China's central bank plans to leverage monetary policies and capitalize on recent economic momentum to boost demand and confidence, with a focus on balancing economic growth and sustainability, according to Pan Gongsheng, governor of the People's Bank of China.