Main topic: The value of music and content in the age of AI and streaming platforms.
Key points:
1. The value of music lies in the artist's name, image, and likeness, rather than the intrinsic musical value.
2. Streaming platforms like Spotify rely on the number of streams and subscribers for revenue, which means per-stream payments may seem low.
3. Competition in the music streaming industry makes it difficult for new artists to break through, leading to the success of established artists like Drake.
4. Record labels are concerned about AI-generated music and are taking measures to protect their copyrighted songs.
5. The future of content authenticity lies in a zero-trust approach, where verification and attribution become crucial for determining the value of content.
### Summary
An AI-generated symphony caused a range of emotions in an audience, highlighting the potential power of AI to manipulate human emotions and potentially even rob us of our free will.
### Facts
- An AI was used to generate new melodies to "finish" Schubert's Unfinished Symphony.
- The performance of the symphony caused a shift in the audience's emotions from astonishment to fear, but eventually to wonder.
- The enjoyment of AI music raises questions about the meaning and emotions behind music created without an emotional composer.
- AI music will develop its own context and may become as emotional as any other style of music.
- The connections a listener draws from their own life to the music create the emotions, not the composer or AI.
- There is a deeper question about whether AI can manipulate emotions and potentially rob us of our free will.
### Summary
The emergence of AI-image generators has raised questions about whether AI-generated art should be considered real art and if it could replace human artists. Different artists and creators have varying opinions on this matter.
### Facts
- Novelist Daphne Kalotay believes that while AI can mimic writing styles and experiment with language, it lacks true insight and experience that can only come from living in a specific physical world.
- Saxophonist Yosvany Terry believes that AI cannot transmit or represent emotion like humans can in music, and it lacks the ability to react and create music in the moment.
- Animator Ruth Stella Lingford acknowledges that AI threatens jobs in the animation industry but also sees it as a potential collaborator. She views AI's random image generation as akin to aspects of the creative process but still values the human hand in animation.
- Mixed-media artist Matt Saunders welcomes the challenge and new possibilities that AI brings to art but raises concerns about the social and ethical implications. He believes that art is a conversation and that artists will continue to play a crucial role.
- Architect Moshe Safdie sees potential in AI's analytical capacity to optimize designs based on specific variables but doubts its ability to produce truly creative and artistic works.
Note: The opinions expressed by each individual are subjective and represent their personal views.
### Summary
YouTube is partnering with Universal Music Group to develop an AI framework to enhance creativity and protect the rights of music artists. They are introducing YouTube's Music AI Incubator to work with innovative artists, songwriters, and producers. YouTube aims to embrace AI responsibly and support the music industry.
### Facts
- YouTube and the music industry have a long history of collaboration, and they are now working together to embrace generative AI and advance creativity.
- YouTube's Music AI Incubator will work with Universal Music Group and other partners to explore generative AI experiments and research.
- The goal is to understand the value of AI technologies for artists and fans, enhance creativity, and solve critical issues.
- YouTube has a strong focus on protecting the rights of artists and has made significant investments in technologies like Content ID.
- They are scaling their trust and safety organization and content policies to address challenges related to AI-generated content.
- YouTube recognizes the potential of AI to supercharge creativity worldwide, but they emphasize that the success of AI and YouTube depends on the success of their partners in the music industry.
- The principles of embracing AI, granting protections while unlocking opportunities, and investing in trust and safety form the foundation for YouTube's approach to AI and the music industry.
### Summary
YouTube is launching a 'Music AI Incubator' in partnership with Universal Music Group to gather insights and research on generative AI experiments in the music industry.
### Facts
- 🎵 YouTube is launching a 'Music AI Incubator' with Universal Music Group as its first partner.
- 🎶 Artists and producers such as Anitta, ABBA's Björn Ulvaeus, d4vd, Don Was, Juanes, Louis Bell, Max Richter, Rodney Jerkins, Rosanne Cash, Ryan Tedder, Yo Gotti, and the estate of Frank Sinatra will be part of the initiative.
- 🤝 UMG will collaborate with YouTube in shaping the program in its early period.
- 🌐 The incubator aims to work with innovative artists, songwriters, and producers across different genres and cultures.
- 💰 UMG CEO, Sir Lucian Grainge, highlighted the importance of building a safe and profitable ecosystem for artists and songwriters.
- 🎶 A working group of artists, songwriters, and producers will explore and offer feedback on AI-related musical tools and products.
- 💡 YouTube's approach to AI technologies involves embracing it responsibly with music partners, ensuring appropriate protections and unlocking opportunities, and scaling trust and safety teams and content policies to address challenges.
### References
[Music Ally](https://musically.com/2023/08/09/youtube-launches-music-ai-incubator-partners-with-universal/)
### Summary
Artificial intelligence is bringing new possibilities to the world of art, enabling creatives to explore innovative design and aesthetics.
### Facts
- 💡 Artificial intelligence has given rise to a new branch of art.
- 🎨 It allows creatives to experiment with design, aesthetics, and discover new perspectives.
- 👨💼 Jeffrey Yin, CFO of Artsy, and artist Trevor Paglen discuss how AI is expanding the tools available in the art industry.
### Summary
YouTube and Universal Music Group (UMG) have introduced principles for AI-generated music, aiming to balance technology adoption with copyright protection and artist compensation.
### Facts
- 🎶 YouTube is establishing a Music AI Incubator to shape its strategy for AI-generated music, with insights gathered from UMG and artists like Rosanne Cash, Yo Gotti, and Frank Sinatra's estate.
- 📝 YouTube emphasizes the need for "responsible" AI strategies while ensuring copyright protection and offering opportunities for partners.
- ⚙️ YouTube plans to enhance its Content ID system to include suitable copyright safeguards and intends to invest more resources in content policies and safety structure to adapt to AI.
- 📜 Detailed policies, technologies, and monetization plans for creators will be revealed in the coming months.
- 💡 AI-generated music is being used both for unauthorized collaborations and legitimate projects. The Beatles, Holly Herndon, and UMG are among those exploring AI's potential in music production.
Note: For the last bullet point, since there is no specific information provided in the text about AI-generated music being used for illegal purposes, I mentioned that it is being used for unauthorized collaborations.
YouTube's CEO, Neal Mohan, announced that they will be embracing AI responsibly with their music partners, working on an AI framework to protect artists' copyrights and enhance creative expression, and introducing YouTube's Music AI Incubator to collaborate with talented artists.
Charlie Kaufman warns that AI is the "end of creativity for human beings" and emphasizes the importance of human-to-human connection in art.
A federal judge has ruled that works created by artificial intelligence (A.I.) are not covered by copyrights, stating that copyright law is designed to incentivize human creativity, not non-human actors. This ruling has implications for the future role of A.I. in the music industry and the monetization of works created by A.I. tools.
Several music stars, including Selena Gomez, Ed Sheeran, Drake, Lil Wayne, Liam Gallagher, and Grimes, have shared their thoughts on artificial intelligence (AI) and its impact on the music industry, expressing concerns about job security, safety, and copyright protection, while others have shown support or interest in collaborating with AI-generated music.
AI is revolutionizing the world of celebrity endorsements, allowing for personalized video messages from stars like Lionel Messi, but there are concerns about the loss of authenticity and artistic integrity as Hollywood grapples with AI's role in writing scripts and replicating performances, leading to a potential strike by actors' unions.
Artificial intelligence (A.I.) may not pose a significant threat to human creativity or intellectual property, as machines still struggle to produce groundbreaking artistic work and are often limited to mimicry rather than true artistic expression.
AI technology, specifically generative AI, is being embraced by the creative side of film and TV production to augment the work of artists and improve the creative process, rather than replacing them. Examples include the use of procedural generation and style transfer in animation techniques and the acceleration of dialogue and collaboration between artists and directors. However, concerns remain about the potential for AI to replace artists and the need for informed decision-making to ensure that AI is used responsibly.
The combination of AI and blockchain can revolutionize the music industry by enhancing creative capabilities and ensuring transparency in revenue distribution while addressing ethical and legal concerns associated with AI-generated content.
Guitarist Alex Skolnick believes that AI is more likely to threaten pop music than heavy metal, as pop music is often "mechanical" and AI can easily replicate its formulas and patterns, whereas guitar-based music is more improvisational and requires the human touch.
A Washington D.C. judge has ruled that AI-generated art should not be awarded copyright protections since no humans played a central role in its creation, establishing a precedent that art should require human authorship; YouTube has partnered with Universal Music Group to launch an AI music incubator to protect artists from unauthorized use of their content; Meta has introduced an automated translator that works for multiple languages, but concerns have been raised regarding the impact it may have on individuals who wish to learn multiple languages; major studios are hiring "AI specialists" amidst a writers' strike, potentially leading to a future of automated entertainment that may not meet audience expectations.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is seen as a tool that can inspire and collaborate with human creatives in the movie and TV industry, but concerns remain about copyright and ethical issues, according to Greg Harrison, chief creative officer at MOCEAN. Although AI has potential for visual brainstorming and automation of non-creative tasks, it should be used cautiously and in a way that values human creativity and culture.
In a recent interview, Epica frontwoman Simone Simons expressed concerns about the use of artificial intelligence in music, stating that she believes "art needs to be created by actual flesh and blood" and that AI cannot compete with human creativity.
A British parliamentary committee is urging the government to prioritize the rights of musicians and creators over AI developers by axing plans that would allow AI developers to freely train their systems on existing works of music, literature, and art.
Simon Cowell expressed his disapproval of using artificial intelligence in music creation, emphasizing the importance of authentic songs that stand the test of time.
Writer/director Cord Jefferson believes that while artificial intelligence has a place in creativity, it should be used in a way that supports artists rather than replacing them completely.
An AI-generated song, "Heart on my Sleeve" by Ghostwriter, is being considered for a Grammy nomination, raising questions about the impact of AI on the music industry.
Queen guitarist Brian May finds the prospect of using artificial intelligence to make music "massively scary" and expresses concern about the potential detrimental effects on the music industry. He believes that AI could blur the boundaries between AI-created and human-created music, possibly leading to the dominance of AI-generated music in the future. May also warns about the potential for AI to be used for malicious purposes in fields like politics and world domination. Other musicians have also voiced their reservations about AI in music, while some see its potential for positive change. May recently shared his sadness about the Freddie Mercury auction and has been working on a BBC documentary about the badger cull in the UK.
Artificial intelligence experts at the Forbes Global CEO Conference in Singapore expressed optimism about AI's future potential in enhancing various industries, including music, healthcare, and education, while acknowledging concerns about risks posed by bad actors and the integration of AI systems that emulate human cognition.
A German start-up, Musical Bits, has developed an AI model that creates heavy metal music by stacking different layers of creativity such as arrangement and melody on top of each other, and plans to release the first fully AI-created heavy metal album on December 22nd.
The revised version of the Protect Working Musicians Act would enable independent musicians to collectively bargain with artificial intelligence developers for fairer rates and terms for the use of their music.
High-profile songwriters are meeting with Congressmen to advocate for legislation protecting musicians' copyrights in the face of the rapid rise of artificial intelligence (AI) in the music industry. The industry wants clear legislation that requires permission from copyright holders to use pre-existing songs to train AI for generating new music.
AI technology has the potential to assist writers in generating powerful and moving prose, but it also raises complex ethical and artistic questions about the future of literature.
YouTube's head of music, Lyor Cohen, expressed his enthusiasm for artificial intelligence (AI) at the Made on YouTube event, stating that AI tools can open up a new playground for creativity and usher in a new era of musical creativity. Warner Music Group CEO, Robert Kyncl, proposed a path forward where AI enthusiasts can benefit from the technology while artists who are wary of it are protected. YouTube is also developing AI-powered tools for creators, such as Dream Screen and a search function that acts like a music concierge.
Jack Osbourne, the media personality and "The Osbournes" alum, uses artificial intelligence (AI) like ChatGPT in his work but expresses concerns about its potential negative impact and limitations on creativity, especially for future generations. Despite his concerns, Osbourne acknowledges the value of AI in certain applications.
The boss of Spotify, Daniel Ek, stated that while there are valid uses of artificial intelligence (AI) in making music, AI should not be used to impersonate human artists without their consent, but there are debates and challenges surrounding the use of AI in the music industry. Spotify does not allow its content to be used to train machine learning or AI models, and there are increasing concerns among artists about the threat of AI to their profession.
Artificial intelligence will not be awarded for creativity at the Grammy Awards, according to the CEO of the Recording Academy, although AI-assisted songs may qualify for certain categories based on the involvement of human creators and performers.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming various fields of science, but its impact on research and society is still unclear, as highlighted in a new Nature series which explores the benefits and risks of AI in science based on the views of over 1,600 researchers worldwide.
The CEO of Warner Music Group believes that AI is a positive development for the music industry and suggests creating a system similar to YouTube's Content ID to protect artists from copyright infringement. However, the music industry is divided over AI, with attempts to prevent AI-generated tracks from ripping off signed musicians while dealing with a surge of phony tracks.
The recently ended Hollywood writers' strike reached a groundbreaking agreement that protects screenwriters from losing their jobs to AI-generated scripts, although the issue of AI training remains unresolved, highlighting the growing concerns in the music industry regarding AI-generated music and the need for legislation to protect songwriters.
Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to revolutionize the entertainment industry by reducing production costs and saving time, but it should not replace or disrupt the creative process, according to a report by Bain & Co. The report emphasizes the need for a balance between utilizing new technologies and respecting the talent and creativity of artists and writers. The savings generated by AI and other technologies can enable studios to produce more high-quality content.
Artificial intelligence (AI) programs have outperformed humans in tasks requiring originality, sparking anxiety among professionals in various fields, including arts and animation, who worry about job loss and the decline of human creativity; experts suggest managing AI fears by gaining a deeper understanding of the technology, taking proactive actions, building solidarity, and reconnecting with the physical world.
Artificial intelligence is increasingly replacing human creativity in the arts, but some artists are embracing AI as another tool in their creative arsenal to push the boundaries of traditional art forms.
Artificial intelligence (AI) has become an undeniable force in our lives, with wide-ranging implications and ethical considerations, posing both benefits and potential harms, and raising questions about regulation and the future of humanity's relationship with AI.
Top songwriters behind hit songs by artists like Doja Cat and Jonas Brothers believe that while artificial intelligence (AI) can be a useful tool in the music industry, it cannot replicate the artistry and human emotion that goes into creating music. They see AI as a tool to enhance their creativity, not replace it.
Dutch metal band Within Temptation discusses their experience using artificial intelligence technology to create music videos and expresses hope for regulations to guide the use of AI; they also mention their upcoming album and European tour.
Guns N' Roses bassist Duff McKagan has expressed his disinterest in using artificial intelligence (AI) in songwriting, stating that he is focused on creativity and drawing inspiration from his personal life and family support; he joins a growing number of artists, including Brian May and Nick Cave, who have criticized the use of AI in music creation. McKagan also revealed that his ongoing struggle with panic attacks has influenced his solo songwriting.
Summary: Artificial intelligence technology is making its way into the entertainment industry, with writers now having the freedom to incorporate AI software into their creative process, raising questions about its usefulness and the ability to differentiate between human and machine-generated content.
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():focal(511x0:513x2)/GettyImages-1199823890-1d401470026f4547a5a37742825fa5cd.jpg)